Post by Lemur, The Kool-Aid Guy on Sept 5, 2011 18:14:42 GMT -5
Name->Weight
Weight should be 'lbs'
Appearance
You should avoid ever using the phrase 'show off the young boy's body,' its kinda pedobear.
Seriously though, he's 26. Even if he does get carded at bars he's still not a boy, young or otherwise.
You also shouldn't mention his habits in this section at all.
Personality
You should avoid mentioning his appearance here. Just the personality would be best.
You also have some sentences that just don't seem to work. I'd go through them line by line to make sure they're clear enough.
Again you call him a kid. It strikes me that if you want him to be a child you should make him a child.
Rank
Consular, fine. But a thrill-seeking childish diplomat? I don't see that working.
Age 1-12
Why did his father fake his own death? There's no point to doing so when anybody can leave the Jedi Order on good terms.
This feels like a very light overview. You should give us some details about his youngling time. Did he have friends? How many? What kind? Did he have any favorite places to hang out? Did he smoke death sticks in the bathrooms? Was he a dutiful student? Did he like his instructors? Was he obedient or was he a rascal?
12-16
You slipped into present tense here. Past is still needed.
At 14 he isn't going to have much advancement in Force Illusion. Its a very difficult power. He'd still be in an incredibly fledgling stage.
You also mention some sort of crystal and power. Even if he doesn't use it, its best to just not mention it.
You don't mention how it is he's selected as a Padawan. That's pretty big, and warrants some details.
16-18
Felucia is a pretty perilous place likely full of adventures and dangers, and for the setting this chunk of his life is pretty empty. Give us some depth here.
What was it like living in the jungles of Felucia? Try to transport the reader there. Mention how it was if he spent two full years there. What did he learn? Did he bond more with his master?
19-24
How did he feel about his new master? What was the change in training styles like for him? Were there trust issues?
Describe these missions. How many? Where to? When? What did he think of them?
Why did he make a second lightsaber? He doesn't do Jar'kai and he didn't lose his first one.
The Trials
What kind of risks was Naboo taking?
I don't see this Spirit working. He needs to face down his own darkness in a serious way.
Skill. You mention Makashi and force valor here, but he has neither of these in his stats. I also don't see a 5 in Shii Cho taking down what is, from your description, one of the most potent masters in the Order.
Flesh. This doesn't work. He suffered no injury, and his master wasn't lost. I also don't see him being capable of defeating with his saber a dark Jedi who defeated a Jedi master. I also am a little vague on why this bad guy would be kidnapping a force sensitive child, or how the Jedi would know any of this to send a rescue mission.
Knighthood (22-26)
After just one year he wouldn't even have 25% of that cloak. Specialized powers are exceedingly rare. Combining them even more so.
Stats
two 7s is a huge stretch, and when combined with three specialized powers its too much. You should probably have one 7 and one specialized power. If you look at accepted characters, no one else has what you want. You can't just have everything.
The other stats are OK though.
RP Sample
This feels like a repeat of the personality section or the bio. Its also present tense.
You should consider working with an RP mentor to improve this. Unlike me, they don't bite.
Overall Impressions
You do have a chronic problem of making such mistakes as 'there' instead of 'their,' 'do' instead of 'due,' etc. You should go through and correct those.
You also keep lapsing into present tense.
I recommend you run this through a word processor to catch spelling and grammar errors.
Weight should be 'lbs'
Appearance
You should avoid ever using the phrase 'show off the young boy's body,' its kinda pedobear.
Seriously though, he's 26. Even if he does get carded at bars he's still not a boy, young or otherwise.
You also shouldn't mention his habits in this section at all.
Personality
You should avoid mentioning his appearance here. Just the personality would be best.
You also have some sentences that just don't seem to work. I'd go through them line by line to make sure they're clear enough.
Again you call him a kid. It strikes me that if you want him to be a child you should make him a child.
Rank
Consular, fine. But a thrill-seeking childish diplomat? I don't see that working.
Age 1-12
Why did his father fake his own death? There's no point to doing so when anybody can leave the Jedi Order on good terms.
This feels like a very light overview. You should give us some details about his youngling time. Did he have friends? How many? What kind? Did he have any favorite places to hang out? Did he smoke death sticks in the bathrooms? Was he a dutiful student? Did he like his instructors? Was he obedient or was he a rascal?
12-16
You slipped into present tense here. Past is still needed.
At 14 he isn't going to have much advancement in Force Illusion. Its a very difficult power. He'd still be in an incredibly fledgling stage.
You also mention some sort of crystal and power. Even if he doesn't use it, its best to just not mention it.
You don't mention how it is he's selected as a Padawan. That's pretty big, and warrants some details.
16-18
Felucia is a pretty perilous place likely full of adventures and dangers, and for the setting this chunk of his life is pretty empty. Give us some depth here.
What was it like living in the jungles of Felucia? Try to transport the reader there. Mention how it was if he spent two full years there. What did he learn? Did he bond more with his master?
19-24
How did he feel about his new master? What was the change in training styles like for him? Were there trust issues?
Describe these missions. How many? Where to? When? What did he think of them?
Why did he make a second lightsaber? He doesn't do Jar'kai and he didn't lose his first one.
The Trials
What kind of risks was Naboo taking?
I don't see this Spirit working. He needs to face down his own darkness in a serious way.
Skill. You mention Makashi and force valor here, but he has neither of these in his stats. I also don't see a 5 in Shii Cho taking down what is, from your description, one of the most potent masters in the Order.
Flesh. This doesn't work. He suffered no injury, and his master wasn't lost. I also don't see him being capable of defeating with his saber a dark Jedi who defeated a Jedi master. I also am a little vague on why this bad guy would be kidnapping a force sensitive child, or how the Jedi would know any of this to send a rescue mission.
Knighthood (22-26)
After just one year he wouldn't even have 25% of that cloak. Specialized powers are exceedingly rare. Combining them even more so.
Stats
two 7s is a huge stretch, and when combined with three specialized powers its too much. You should probably have one 7 and one specialized power. If you look at accepted characters, no one else has what you want. You can't just have everything.
The other stats are OK though.
RP Sample
This feels like a repeat of the personality section or the bio. Its also present tense.
You should consider working with an RP mentor to improve this. Unlike me, they don't bite.
Overall Impressions
You do have a chronic problem of making such mistakes as 'there' instead of 'their,' 'do' instead of 'due,' etc. You should go through and correct those.
You also keep lapsing into present tense.
I recommend you run this through a word processor to catch spelling and grammar errors.